The Best Cyprus Community

Skip to content


The January 1950 “Referendum for ENOSIS” under Makarios II

How can we solve it? (keep it civilized)

Postby Oracle » Tue May 06, 2008 8:01 am

Eric dayi wrote:
Oracle wrote:
Eric dayi wrote:The EU is worse than the UN was in the 60's and 70's.


Why would Turkey be so desperate to join such an awful establishment then? :?


In case you have forgotten Erdogan said "it isn't the end of the world for Turkey if Turkey is not allowed to join the EU" (or similar).

Turkey has also been pressured to recognise the so-called "RoC" but Turkey hasn't.

The support for the EU accession in Turkey is falling.

Does that sound like Turkey is "desperate to join"?


Well Erdogan would say that wouldn't he as he wants to protect his Islamic Interests .... and I am with him on this one :lol:

No really, I don't understand why Turkey as a square peg is trying to fit into a round hole. Whittling away at its identity is rather pathetic, especially since they are not addressing the real issues like legalities, Human rights abuses etc. but just trying to become more "westernised" by picking on things like clothes (i.e. legalising choice on headscarves and such like).

Again not recognising the RoC is just another of these choices where they fail to address the right issues for entry whilst ignoring the important ones.

As it is Turkey just wants to swallow up Cyprus whether it gets in or not ... hence the tenacious denial of the RoC.
User avatar
Oracle
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 23507
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 11:13 am
Location: Anywhere but...

Postby Nikitas » Tue May 06, 2008 8:12 am

When you join a club you accept its rules. You do not ask for a change of rules so you can join. No recognition of Cyprus means no entry. Not because of Cyprus objecting, but becasue the other members will not let Turkey dictate membership terms.
Nikitas
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 7420
Joined: Thu Aug 09, 2007 2:49 pm

Postby DT. » Tue May 06, 2008 8:12 am

FullMetalTurk wrote:
Piratis wrote:Lets get some facts straight:

1) Cyprus is as Greek as any other Greek territory and island. .



"lets get some facts staright" lets do.
the very first people to discover cyprus were nomads from the middle east who sailed to the island, resided temporarily, then left. this was in 8000 BC. then came the Khirokitians who died out a few centuries later. then followed Hittite and ancient egyptian rule in 2000 BC. Hellenistic rule was only between 333 and 58 BC - just 275 years. then until 1571 it was roman - byzantine, venetian etc.
the fact is, greeks have always lived on the island after the ancient egyptians left, but cyprus has never been a greek island. if you call it a roman island fair enough, because it was under byzantine and venetian rule, but then i would have the right to call it an ottoman island.


What the hell do you think the Byzantine empire was? The standard on this forum is really dropping. :roll:
User avatar
DT.
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 12682
Joined: Sun Nov 12, 2006 8:34 pm
Location: Lefkosia

Postby bilako22 » Tue May 06, 2008 8:26 am

DT. wrote:
FullMetalTurk wrote:
Piratis wrote:Lets get some facts straight:

1) Cyprus is as Greek as any other Greek territory and island. .



"lets get some facts staright" lets do.
the very first people to discover cyprus were nomads from the middle east who sailed to the island, resided temporarily, then left. this was in 8000 BC. then came the Khirokitians who died out a few centuries later. then followed Hittite and ancient egyptian rule in 2000 BC. Hellenistic rule was only between 333 and 58 BC - just 275 years. then until 1571 it was roman - byzantine, venetian etc.
the fact is, greeks have always lived on the island after the ancient egyptians left, but cyprus has never been a greek island. if you call it a roman island fair enough, because it was under byzantine and venetian rule, but then i would have the right to call it an ottoman island.


What the hell do you think the Byzantine empire was? The standard on this forum is really dropping. :roll:


Come on guys , trying to use history as a way to claim ownership of Cyprus is pure nonsense . After all , based on those same rules most of Turkey should be owned by the Greeks.
User avatar
bilako22
Contributor
Contributor
 
Posts: 333
Joined: Fri Dec 28, 2007 9:57 am

Postby DT. » Tue May 06, 2008 8:34 am

bilako22 wrote:
DT. wrote:
FullMetalTurk wrote:
Piratis wrote:Lets get some facts straight:

1) Cyprus is as Greek as any other Greek territory and island. .



"lets get some facts staright" lets do.
the very first people to discover cyprus were nomads from the middle east who sailed to the island, resided temporarily, then left. this was in 8000 BC. then came the Khirokitians who died out a few centuries later. then followed Hittite and ancient egyptian rule in 2000 BC. Hellenistic rule was only between 333 and 58 BC - just 275 years. then until 1571 it was roman - byzantine, venetian etc.
the fact is, greeks have always lived on the island after the ancient egyptians left, but cyprus has never been a greek island. if you call it a roman island fair enough, because it was under byzantine and venetian rule, but then i would have the right to call it an ottoman island.


What the hell do you think the Byzantine empire was? The standard on this forum is really dropping. :roll:


Come on guys , trying to use history as a way to claim ownership of Cyprus is pure nonsense . After all , based on those same rules most of Turkey should be owned by the Greeks.


:lol: :lol: :lol:
User avatar
DT.
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 12682
Joined: Sun Nov 12, 2006 8:34 pm
Location: Lefkosia

Postby Piratis » Tue May 06, 2008 8:50 am

FullMetalTurk wrote:
Piratis wrote:Lets get some facts straight:

1) Cyprus is as Greek as any other Greek territory and island. .



"lets get some facts staright" lets do.
the very first people to discover cyprus were nomads from the middle east who sailed to the island, resided temporarily, then left. this was in 8000 BC. then came the Khirokitians who died out a few centuries later. then followed Hittite and ancient egyptian rule in 2000 BC. Hellenistic rule was only between 333 and 58 BC - just 275 years. then until 1571 it was roman - byzantine, venetian etc.
the fact is, greeks have always lived on the island after the ancient egyptians left, but cyprus has never been a greek island. if you call it a roman island fair enough, because it was under byzantine and venetian rule, but then i would have the right to call it an ottoman island.


Cyprus was never part of the Hittite empire, and it was under Egypt rule much later, and only for some decades, at around the 7th century BC.

The Greeks were among the first people to come to Cyprus and they did so at around 1400BC, not 333. (333 was when Alexander the Great liberated Cypriots from the Persians.)


After 1400 B.C., Mycenaean and Mycenaean-Achaean traders from the northeastern Peloponnesus began regular commercial visits to the island. Settlers from the same areas arrived in large numbers toward the end of the Trojan War (traditionally dated about 1184 B.C.). Even in modern times, a strip of the northern coast was known as the Achaean Coast in commemoration of those early settlers. The newcomers spread the use of their spoken language and introduced a script that greatly facilitated commerce. They also introduced the potter's wheel and began producing pottery that eventually was carried by traders to many mainland markets. By the end of the second millennium B.C., a distinctive culture had developed on Cyprus. The island's culture was tempered and enriched by its position as a crossroads for the commerce of three continents, but in essence it was distinctively Hellenic.


When the Greeks first came to Cyprus most of the island was uninhabited. Unlike the foreign rulers that came after (Egyptians, Persians, Ottomans, British etc) the Greeks came to Cyprus and created their own cities and made Cyprus their home. On the contrary those foreign rulers didn't create their own cities like the Greeks (and Phoenicians) did, but simply send their troops to our island with the aim to enslave and exploit Cyprus and its people.

Cyprus is Greek because its people and culture are Greek in their great majority and they have been so for 1000s of years. Few nations today can claim such a long history on the territories they currently inhabit.

It always amazes me when some people come to claim that Cyprus is not Greek and then they can not explain how Cypriots speak Greek and follow a Greek religion (Olympus Gods, then Orthodox Christianity) and Greek culture. Apparently these people confuse what Cyprus is with the who rules Cyprus against the will of Cypriots.

Lets compare Cyprus and Asia Minor for example. Is Asia Minor Turkish and should it be called "Turkey"?

The Greeks came to Cyprus 3500 years ago, and they were among the first inhabitants of the island and created their own new cities.

The Turks went to Asia Minor just 600 years ago, and they arrived there as invadors, killing and stealing the lands and cities others before them had created.

The Greeks are the 80% majority in Cyprus. The Turkish minority was created by means of force during the Ottoman rule, otherwise GCs would have been an even greater majority on the island.

The Turks are the 80% majority in Asia Minor. They became the majority by killing millions of Armenians, Kurds and Greeks. If they had not done so they would not be the majority in Asia Minor.

So if you claim that Cyprus is not Greek because some tribes had arrived in Cyprus before the Greeks, then you certainly can not claim that Asia Minor is Turkish.
User avatar
Piratis
Moderator
Moderator
 
Posts: 12261
Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2004 11:08 pm

Postby Oracle » Tue May 06, 2008 8:52 am

DT. wrote:
FullMetalTurk wrote:
Piratis wrote:Lets get some facts straight:

1) Cyprus is as Greek as any other Greek territory and island. .



"lets get some facts staright" lets do.
the very first people to discover cyprus were nomads from the middle east who sailed to the island, resided temporarily, then left. this was in 8000 BC. then came the Khirokitians who died out a few centuries later. then followed Hittite and ancient egyptian rule in 2000 BC. Hellenistic rule was only between 333 and 58 BC - just 275 years. then until 1571 it was roman - byzantine, venetian etc.
the fact is, greeks have always lived on the island after the ancient egyptians left, but cyprus has never been a greek island. if you call it a roman island fair enough, because it was under byzantine and venetian rule, but then i would have the right to call it an ottoman island.


What the hell do you think the Byzantine empire was? The standard on this forum is really dropping. :roll:


I think FullMetalTurk must be suffering from the debilitating effects of Lead poisoning :lol:
User avatar
Oracle
Leading Contributor
Leading Contributor
 
Posts: 23507
Joined: Mon Feb 11, 2008 11:13 am
Location: Anywhere but...

Postby Nikitas » Tue May 06, 2008 8:56 am

Byzantine is not Greek? Really! How come Byzantines spoke and wrote Greek and all scholars regard it as a Greek empire? Not so long ago I made some good money translating Byzantine texts into English. I am sure as hell not a Byzantine speaker!

Naturally using the word Roman to describe a major part of Greek history diminishes its duration in small minds. Cheap tricks!
Nikitas
Main Contributor
Main Contributor
 
Posts: 7420
Joined: Thu Aug 09, 2007 2:49 pm

Postby Piratis » Tue May 06, 2008 8:59 am

bilako22 wrote:
DT. wrote:
FullMetalTurk wrote:
Piratis wrote:Lets get some facts straight:

1) Cyprus is as Greek as any other Greek territory and island. .



"lets get some facts staright" lets do.
the very first people to discover cyprus were nomads from the middle east who sailed to the island, resided temporarily, then left. this was in 8000 BC. then came the Khirokitians who died out a few centuries later. then followed Hittite and ancient egyptian rule in 2000 BC. Hellenistic rule was only between 333 and 58 BC - just 275 years. then until 1571 it was roman - byzantine, venetian etc.
the fact is, greeks have always lived on the island after the ancient egyptians left, but cyprus has never been a greek island. if you call it a roman island fair enough, because it was under byzantine and venetian rule, but then i would have the right to call it an ottoman island.


What the hell do you think the Byzantine empire was? The standard on this forum is really dropping. :roll:


Come on guys , trying to use history as a way to claim ownership of Cyprus is pure nonsense . After all , based on those same rules most of Turkey should be owned by the Greeks.


Cyprus is Greek because Greek is the dominant culture, Greek is the dominant language and Greek Orthodoxy the dominant religion. Using history is just to show the natural way that Cyprus became Greek, as opposed to the forceful and criminal way that the Turks today are trying to make Turkish the north part of our island by means of invasion, ethnic cleansing, transfer of 10s of thousands of Turkish settlers, renaming our villages, and trying to destroy the true identity of the north part of our island in order to create some fake "Turkish" state on it.

Cyprus is owned by its people, TC minority included. But you can not ethnically cleanse the majority of Cypriots from part of their island because you want your own separate Turkish state on Cyprus.
User avatar
Piratis
Moderator
Moderator
 
Posts: 12261
Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2004 11:08 pm

Postby Piratis » Tue May 06, 2008 9:01 am

Viewpoint wrote:
Piratis wrote:Lets get some facts straight:

1) Cyprus is as Greek as any other Greek territory and island. Cyprus has been occupied by foreign rulers, just like the rest of Greece, and Cyprus was part of the Ottoman empire, just like the rest of Greece. In fact the Turks occupied Athens and many other Greek (and not only) territories for far longer than they occupied Cyprus. Similarly, Turkish (Muslim) minorities were formed in many other Greek territories and islands (and most other territories the Ottomans occupied).

2) The Greek state was formed when Greek territories and islands were gradually liberated from their foreign rulers. The first territories were liberated with the revolution of 1821, and the last territories to unite (=enosis) with the Greek state were liberated in 1948.

3) Liberation from foreign rulers meant Cyprus becoming part part of the free Greek state, like it happened to those other territories earlier, and that is what the native in their great majority Cypriots wanted.

4) At that time the Church leadership was what represented Cypriots, since we were not allowed to elect our own goverment.

5) The referendum/petition that you talk about in this thread happened exactly because our foreign rulers did not allow the Cypriot people to decide in a democratic way their own destiny. Some years earlier the British themselves were promising to Greece that they would allow Cyprus to be part of the Greek state if Greece had joined the war on their side. Apparently it was OK for them to trade Cyprus as they wished, but not OK to let the Cypriot people decide the destiny of their own island in a democratic way.

6) The Cypriots after having Turks, British and others taking the decisions for their own island they simply wanted the freedom to decide the destiny of their own territory, something that naturally translated to union with Greece, one of the 3 legitimate options according to the UN resolution for decolonization. We didn't want any conflict or any harm to anybody else, and no harm would have been caused if some foreigners (British and Turks) did not insist on imposing their rule over our island. When we started our liberation struggle in 1955 we exclusively targeted the colonialists and nobody else. The conflict with TCs started only when the TCs attacked us, and when they started making demands that we should be exterminated from half of our island.

7) The first one to ever propose independence for Cyprus was Makarios. Until then nobody had thought of such thing, thats why there was actually no independent island in the Mediterranean sea. Cyprus is too small to be truly independent, and obviously Cypriots would prefer to be part of a free Greek state, than to continue to be ruled by British and Turks.

8) A Cypriot is as Cypriot as a Cretan is a Cretan, and as an Athenian is an Athenian. Being Greek and being Cypriot is not something contradictory. I am Limassolian, Cypriot, Greek, European, human on planet earth. Being from Limassol doesn't mean I can not be Cypriot. It actually means I am most probably Cypriot. And being Cypriot means that I am most probably Greek. And being Greek means that I am European.

When you talk about an era you have to consider the facts of that era. Comparing for example the role of the church back then with its role today is somehting completely wrong.


Malta, much smaller and independent.


Malta became independent in 1964. In 1950 that we are talking about here there was no independent island in the Mediterranean.
User avatar
Piratis
Moderator
Moderator
 
Posts: 12261
Joined: Tue Mar 09, 2004 11:08 pm

PreviousNext

Return to Cyprus Problem

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest